David Corenswet has expressed interest in portraying a darker, R-rated version of Superman, a vision that aligns with a compelling DC Comics storyline James Gunn could adapt for the DC Universe (DCU). This concept fits well with the announced DCU project, The Authority, potentially enriching the Man of Steel’s future on screen.
David Corenswet’s Vision for a Grittier Superman
Although James Gunn’s current approach to Superman focuses on a lighter and family-friendly portrayal, there is growing anticipation for a more mature take on the character. David Corenswet shared with Nerdist his desire to explore a Superman that embraces a darker, more complex tone. He suggested an R-rated project that carries the atmosphere of a crime thriller, similar to the tone of True Detective, rather than graphic violence like seen in The Boys.
“I would love to see this Superman in an R-rated project… in a thing like Lanterns where it’s that True Detective’ feel.”
—David Corenswet, Actor
He further emphasized the potential flexibility in Superman’s tone, despite the character’s traditionally bright and hopeful image.
“In spite of how bright and playful this version is, I think there’s room to be flexible.”
—David Corenswet, Actor
Given this perspective, an opportunity arises for James Gunn to explore a more nuanced and mature storyline in upcoming DCU productions, providing depth to Corenswet’s Superman and expanding the universe’s tonal possibilities.
A Compelling DC Comic as a Blueprint for a Darker Superman
One potential story that fits this vision is the 2001 comic
“What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, & the American Way,”
written by Joe Kelly. This narrative introduces The Elite, a group of extreme heroes known for their ruthless tactics, including killing terrorists without hesitation. Their controversial methods gain widespread public support, challenging Superman’s traditional heroic ideals.
Superman confronts The Elite, resulting in a brutal battle transported to Io, one of Jupiter’s moons. The Elite land several critical blows on him before an invisible Superman begins to systematically take them down. The final confrontation reveals a deeper moral debate, highlighting Superman’s commitment to justice and ethics even in the face of lethal opposition. This story underscores the conflict between raw power wielded without restraint and the enduring values Superman upholds.
Such a storyline offers James Gunn a chance to craft an R-rated Superman narrative filled with moral complexity and darker themes, aligning well with Corenswet’s call for a grittier portrayal.
How This Story Connects to the DCU Project The Authority
James Gunn has also confirmed that The Authority, a new DCU project, is in development. The Authority is a team of superheroes who act independently of political or legal constraints, often engaging in revolutions and coups to reshape the world according to their vision. Their disregard for traditional rules closely parallels the aggressive tactics of The Elite from the comic.
This connection creates an opportunity for the Superman storyline to intersect with The Authority, potentially positioning Corenswet’s Superman as a counterforce to this morally ambiguous team. This interaction could extend the themes explored in
“What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, & the American Way,”
allowing the DCU to delve into a richer, darker narrative arc.
By integrating these stories, James Gunn can give Corenswet’s Superman the depth and complexity he envisions, while also advancing the broader DCU narrative with high-stakes conflicts and mature themes.
The Anticipated Impact on the DC Cinematic Universe
David Corenswet’s Superman is set to debut in theaters on July 11, 2025. If James Gunn decides to adapt the darker comic storylines and incorporate The Authority, it could mark a significant tonal shift in the DCU, appealing to audiences seeking more serious and sophisticated superhero tales. This approach would contrast with past Superman films while remaining true to the character’s core principles by exploring the challenges of maintaining justice in a morally complex world.
Fans and critics alike await to see if this vision materializes, as it promises a fresh and intense chapter for the iconic Man of Steel that balances grit with enduring heroism.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is David Corenswet taller than Henry Cavill?
A. At 6’4, he was considered slightly too tall since Cavill is 6’1.
