James Gunn recently described Supergirl as “kind of a mess” while discussing her upcoming debut in the DC Universe (DCU), highlighting the challenges Kara Zor-El faces compared to her cousin, Superman. This portrayal resonates with the established DC Comics canon, which depicts Supergirl’s journey as more complicated and fraught with personal struggles than Clark Kent’s.
Unlike Superman, who had a relatively sheltered start on Earth, Supergirl’s origins involve significant trauma and adjustment difficulties. Living under the shadow of her revered cousin and navigating the expectations tied to his legacy presents unique obstacles for Kara, making her story far more complex and emotionally charged.
Supergirl’s Most Defining Comic Series Validates Gunn’s Viewpoint
Among various iterations, Kara Zor-El remains the most recognized Supergirl, officially reintroduced into the main DC continuity in 2004. A year later, she starred in her own comic series, which gained momentum particularly after issue #34 with the creative input of Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle. Their run focused heavily on the complexities of her character, contrasting sharply with Superman’s widespread acceptance.
This version of Supergirl was portrayed as a hero grappling with her imperfections rather than an untouchable icon. Her impulsiveness and risky decisions, such as hurling a truck at an adversary in the middle of a public baseball game, underscored her flaws. These tough moments were further aggravated as the Daily Planet’s columnist Cat Grant actively criticized her, delivering harsh op-eds that undermined Kara’s confidence.
Facing constant comparisons to Superman only deepened Kara’s internal conflicts. While Superman embodies near-ideal Kryptonian virtues, Supergirl struggled to meet those elevated standards, which amplified her sense of inadequacy and frustration.
Despite making mistakes and sometimes unintentionally hurting those she cared about, Kara’s resilience shone through. The comics emphasize that no matter the criticism or personal setbacks, Supergirl perseveres, continuously rising to protect the world.
The Traumatic Origins That Set Supergirl Apart From Superman
Superman was a toddler during Krypton’s destruction, making his memories of the planet faint and distant. In contrast, Supergirl was already a teenager who witnessed her home’s devastation firsthand, losing her family, friends, and entire culture. This harrowing experience profoundly shaped her character and created emotional scars not seen in Clark Kent’s story.
DC writers have explored how these events left Kara with symptoms resembling post-traumatic stress disorder, survivor’s guilt, and occasional bouts of anger tied to her lost past. These elements often surface during conflicts, especially when villains or situations trigger memories of Krypton’s destruction.
While Superman’s origin is tragic, Kara’s forced transition from a familiar world where everything made sense to Earth, where she was a stranger under immense pressure, carries unique weight. Being the last known Kryptonian doubly burdened her, as her only living relative became an immense standard she was expected to match.
Kara’s Imperfections Highlight Her Humanity and Make Her Relatable
Is it accurate to label Supergirl as “kind of a mess”? Given the trials she endures at the onset of her journey, the answer is yes. Kara’s experiences differ greatly from Superman’s, and these challenges manifest in ways that occasionally make her erratic or vulnerable.
This ‘messiness’ adds depth to her character, making her feel more human and less like an unattainable superhero ideal. Kara’s flaws—her mistakes, doubts, and emotional struggles—mirror the imperfections found in real-life individuals, which renders her story more approachable and resonant.
Far from detracting from her role, Supergirl’s struggles enhance her narrative by portraying her as someone who knows she isn’t perfect yet strives to do her best. The comics repeatedly show her determination, intelligence, and optimism, qualities that drive her forward despite her setbacks.
So, while James Gunn’s description of Supergirl as a “mess” rings true, it also reveals a heroine who embodies resilience and hope, fighting not only external villains but also her internal battles as she carves out her place in the DC Universe.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Does James Gunn believe in God?
A. Gunn grew up in a Catholic household. He says praying is still important to him. However, he also describes himself as somewhat against religion.
Q. Why is James Gunn leaving Marvel?
A. When Gunn took on the role of co-CEO at DC Studios, he committed solely to that company. This decision meant he would stop working on Marvel Studios’ projects. It’s well-known that Gunn, who wrote and directed the Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy, developed strong connections with its actors.
