Viewers have noticed a striking Ryan Reynolds resemblance in Wicked: For Good, focusing attention on Jonathan Bailey’s portrayal of the Scarecrow during the film’s ending. The resemblance has sparked strong reactions across social media, with the topic gaining momentum after the movie’s recent release.
Jonathan Bailey returned as Prince Fiyero in the follow-up to the blockbuster 2024 Wicked film, sharing the screen with notable cast members including Ariana Grande, Cynthia Erivo, Michelle Yeoh, and Jeff Goldblum. This chapter covers the second act of the original stage musical, which has captivated audiences since its Broadway debut in 2003.
Fans React to the Scarecrow’s Striking Likeness
Soon after the film premiered, fans highlighted how closely Jonathan Bailey as the Scarecrow resembled Ryan Reynolds, with many taking to social media to share their observations and humor. Online threads and posts multiplied as more viewers joined the conversation, with some fans expressing bewilderment over the likeness and even calling for playful investigations. One user asked,
“why does jonathan bailey as scarecrow looks like ryan reynolds…we need to open an investigation”
— ivy (@ohhhhhherewegoo)
“You’re telling me this ISN’T Ryan Reynolds.”
— Unattributed
The resemblance became a trending topic, prompting both amusement and speculation among those watching Wicked: For Good. Even more perplexed viewers emphasized just how similar the two actors appeared on screen, fueling lively exchanges online.
Debate Over the Scarecrow’s Makeup and Design
While the comparisons to Ryan Reynolds captivated many fans, some voiced frustration over the visual choices for the Scarecrow. These opinions centered on the makeup and prosthetics used to transform Bailey into his character. A user commented,
“My only BIG complaint (rest are nitpicking) is how Fiyero looks as the Scarecrow. I don’t know if anybody was thinking when making his face makeup.”
— Unattributed
This feedback highlights the mixed emotions among fans, where delight over playful resemblances exists alongside disappointment regarding creative decisions. Such discussions have kept the new film in the spotlight well after its release.
Wicked: For Good’s Continued Success Despite Divided Reactions
The online debate has coincided with Wicked: For Good achieving remarkable box office performance, surpassing the debut numbers of its predecessor. Despite criticism surrounding elements of the Scarecrow’s appearance, the film has earned a strong reception from both critics and the general audience, inviting speculation that it could become one of the year’s most successful movies. Entities like Jonathan Bailey, Ariana Grande, Cynthia Erivo, Michelle Yeoh, Jeff Goldblum, and the character Scarecrow continue to be central to ongoing discussion, while media sources such as Mandatory and reporters like Preksha Sharma document the public’s varied perspectives.
As fan conversations continue online, the Ryan Reynolds resemblance in Wicked remains a prominent talking point, adding another dimension to the movie’s cultural footprint and ensuring the character’s transformation is remembered as one of its most debated elements.
why does jonathan bailey as scarecrow looks like ryan reynolds…we need to open an investigation pic.twitter.com/PfkREuWMO7
— ivy (@ohhhhhherewegoo) November 21, 2025
