Speculation about the Chris Evans Captain America Return gained momentum after newly released Avengers: Doomsday fan art imagined what Steve Rogers’ next Marvel Cinematic Universe appearance could look like. Despite Marvel omitting Evans’ name from the official cast announcement, fans continue to wonder if he could reprise the role in the highly anticipated movie.
Fresh Art Imagines a Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter Reunion
Marvel enthusiasts were quick to notice that during Marvel’s much-publicized stream revealing the latest Avengers lineup, Chris Evans was notably absent from the list of returning stars, even as familiar faces like Chris Hemsworth and Robert Downey Jr. were included. The absence triggered questions about whether Evans’ Captain America story may not be over yet, especially as persistent industry rumors suggest he remains involved, a claim Evans has publicly denied until now.
Adding fuel to the speculation, Instagram artist @yugraphics00 recently shared a detailed vision of an Avengers: Doomsday scene featuring both Captain America and Peggy Carter back in action. The artwork places Peggy in a military uniform reminiscent of her MCU roots, not the superhero attire she sported in What If…? or Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. This creative choice fits, as the last time viewers saw Peggy Carter onscreen was at the end of Avengers: Endgame, where she and Steve Rogers settled into life in the 1940s timeline. Another twist in the fan illustration is Captain America’s beard, providing a new look for the returning hero.
Rumors and Industry Reports Spark Debate Over Evans and Atwell’s Roles
Links between the fresh artwork and ongoing casting news have kept speculation alive for months. While neither Chris Evans nor Hayley Atwell, who has played Peggy Carter, were officially announced as part of the next Avengers film, this does not definitively rule out their involvement. For many, it would make sense for Marvel to keep any such cameos under wraps, especially since Endgame brought emotional closure to both characters.
Reports circulated nearly a year ago, as early as December 2024, painting a different picture—insiders suggested that Evans had been slated to return in Avengers: Doomsday, with Atwell joining shortly after. There were even claims from 2021, when reconciling contracts and creative direction, that Marvel nearly greenlit a Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter–focused project.
Evans himself stirred the discussion further when he admitted in an interview with ScreenRant that he felt,
sad to not be back with the band,
Chris Evans, Actor, yet he still maintained he was not on the official cast list for the upcoming Avengers outing. Meanwhile, Atwell told Den of Geek she is open to returning, sharing her enthusiasm about future Avengers movies but avoiding any outright confirmation of Marvel’s intentions.
Strategic Impact of Captain America and Peggy Carter’s Potential MCU Comeback
From a narrative perspective, fans argue that the return of Evans’ Captain America in a movie featuring Doctor Doom, portrayed again by Robert Downey Jr., would be narratively necessary. Given the ongoing Multiverse Saga within the MCU, stories crossing timelines and dimensions disrupt established reality, and the emotional finale between Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter in Endgame should generate lasting consequences. Those consequences, some believe, could create new connections between Captain America and pivotal villains like Doctor Doom.
Steve and Peggy’s last shared scene was as a couple, closing out a decade-long arc for both. Their reappearance, especially in a film directed by the Russo Brothers—well regarded for their work on previous Captain America films—would only seem natural. The Russo Brothers’ reputation for collaborating effectively with Evans could also be a decisive factor if Evans is persuaded to suit up as Captain America once again.
Avengers: Doomsday Cast Highlights
While Chris Evans’ involvement is uncertain, confirmed cast members bring together familiar and new faces. Chris Hemsworth will return as Thor, maintaining his integral position in the group. Vanessa Kirby joins the lineup as Sue Storm, also known as Invisible Woman, expected to have a major role in the story. Joseph Quinn steps in as Johnny Storm, or Human Torch, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach appears as Ben Grimm, also known as The Thing. Together, these names offer a fresh dynamic for the evolving Avengers roster, even as rumors swirl about the inclusion of Captain America and Peggy Carter.
The official lineup’s absence of Chris Evans and Hayley Atwell, along with persistent fan predictions and creative speculation, signals unresolved questions about their characters’ destinies. As anticipation grows and Marvel remains silent, any possible comeback could deliver a major emotional punch to longtime fans awaiting confirmation of the Chris Evans Captain America Return.
