Speculation is building that Andrew Garfield might suit up again as Spider-Man in the highly anticipated Avengers: Doomsday, with new fan art fueling excitement about a potential reunion with Tobey Maguire and Tom Holland. The topic of Andrew Garfield Avengers Doomsday Spider-Man has captured the attention of Marvel Cinematic Universe fans, as rumors swirl about what the Russo brothers’ next crossover could mean for the franchise.
Fan Art Fuels Rumors of Multiverse Spider-Man Comeback
Recent fan creations have sparked talk of all three modern Spider-Man actors—Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland—appearing together once more in the MCU. The trio previously delighted audiences in Spider-Man: No Way Home, released in 2021, when they joined forces to defeat major villains from alternate realities who threatened the stability of Earth 616. As Holland prepares for his next solo trilogy, beginning with Spider-Man: Brand New Day in 2026, attention is turning to how other versions of Peter Parker might reenter the storyline.
Enthusiastic speculation follows artwork posted by Instagram creator @spdrmnkyxxiii, which imagines a dramatic and darker scenario for the three Spider-Men, set against the backdrop of the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. Although Tom Holland is seen as the MCU’s current Peter Parker, both Maguire and Garfield have become fan favorites for the continuing exploration of different multiverse realities.
Possibility of Spider-Man Variants Joining Forces in Avengers: Doomsday
Official announcements about the cast of Avengers: Doomsday remain under wraps, with no confirmation yet for the return of Garfield, Maguire, or Holland. Nevertheless, their potential inclusion seems natural given the multiversal themes expected in the movie. With Holland’s next Spider-Man film scheduled for July 2026, just months before Avengers: Doomsday’s December 2026 release, many hope plot threads will connect the two, paving the way for another high-stakes encounter. The presence of Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom also adds an intriguing layer, especially considering how Peter Parker might react to a villain who resembles his former mentor.
According to discussions among fans and industry observers, Avengers: Doomsday is set to follow Doctor Doom as he travels across different realities, trying to prevent universe-destroying incursions by eradicating alternate worlds. The narrative may take Doom from the Fantastic Four’s Earth 828, to the Illuminati’s Earth 838, and on through the X-Men’s Earth 10005, before his arrival on Earth 616—the main MCU timeline. In franchise lore, the world from Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man films, starring Maguire, is known as Earth 96283, while Garfield’s The Amazing Spider-Man universe aligns with Earth 120703. This opens the door for Doctor Doom’s path to cross with every version of Spider-Man Marvel has ever presented in film.
Timeline Changes Could Bring Major MCU Crossover
The aftermath of Spider-Man: No Way Home plays a crucial storytelling role for Avengers: Doomsday. In the previous MCU entry, five supervillains were returned to their respective home realities after being cured, which could have significant consequences for the timeline in each universe. These disruptions might now provoke large-scale incursions that Doctor Doom will need to address in Doomsday, with the three Spider-Men aligning to face the threat. Despite ongoing denials from Garfield regarding his involvement—echoing his pre-No Way Home stance—and silence from Maguire, many fans are eager to see if both actors will share the screen with Holland in another cosmic showdown.
While there has been no official statement from the actors or Marvel Studios, the possibility of the Spider-Men joining forces again remains one of the most talked-about ideas heading into the next MCU phase. The inclusion of even more Spider-people from parallel worlds could raise the stakes further, possibly leading to the biggest multiverse crossover yet as the MCU navigates a storyline spanning everything from the Fantastic Four and X-Men to iconic Spider-Man realities crafted by Sam Raimi and Marc Webb.
Potential Impact of a Spider-Man Team-Up Against Doctor Doom
The multiverse direction of Avengers: Doomsday, under the helm of the Russo brothers, positions it to be one of the most consequential crossover events in cinematic superhero history. The return of Maguire and Garfield alongside Holland would represent a convergence of Spider-Man legacies, offering fans a collective battle against Robert Downey Jr.’s Doctor Doom—a villain unlike any previous MCU antagonist.
This anticipated plot could have ripple effects across interconnected MCU properties. With the storyline potentially referencing incursions sparked by actions in No Way Home and crossing through numerous established Marvel realities, Avengers: Doomsday may tie together years of storytelling from multiple franchises, uniting fan-favorite heroes and villains in a high-stakes narrative. Such a film would not only offer nostalgia but also shape the MCU’s multiverse for years to come, especially if it serves as a capstone to the current phase or launches new stories exploring alternate Earths and timelines.
Marvel fans, including admirers of the original Spider-Man trilogies and The Amazing Spider-Man films, are closely watching for any news of Andrew Garfield or Tobey Maguire returning. The involvement of director Sam Raimi’s universe, the upcoming solo adventures of Tom Holland’s Spider-Man, and casting decisions regarding Doctor Doom, all underline Avengers: Doomsday as a watershed moment in the MCU. As speculation continues, fans are urged to stay tuned and engage in forums and discussions to share their hopes and theories for what many believe could be the ultimate Spider-Man crossover.
