When Danny DeVito joined the cast of “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia” in its second season, the move marked a pivotal turning point for the series. The addition of the veteran actor was a strategic move by FX, spearheaded by CEO John Landgraf, to bolster the show’s visibility. In the beginning, however, the original cast members harbored reservations about introducing such a high-profile star. DeVito’s fame and cinematic prowess were undeniable, yet his integration into the show’s unique dynamic was uncertain. This significant casting decision would ultimately redefine the show’s future.
Initially, Kaitlin Olson and her fellow cast members expressed apprehension about the change. Their concern stemmed from DeVito’s vast experience as a renowned movie star. At that time, “It’s Always Sunny” was still in its nascent stage—a six-episode debut season trying to captivate a loyal audience. Despite Landgraf’s responsible insight into the show’s latent potential, the idea of enlisting a celebrity was not met with enthusiasm by the team. This stemmed from the show’s grassroots origins and the cast’s modest profiles, which contributed to its underground allure.
The introduction of Danny DeVito became a critical catalyst for the show’s success. The crew initially feared that incorporating a wildly successful actor might disrupt the series’ distinctive offbeat charm. Yet, DeVito’s contribution far exceeded their expectations, turning “It’s Always Sunny” from a cult gem into a celebrated television staple. Reflecting on the decision in an interview with Basic!, Olson recounted the struggle for attention in the early days. She emphasized the necessity of attracting viewers without diminishing the authentic essence of their small-scale production.
By the time DeVito graced the screen of “It’s Always Sunny,” his presence was already well-known through films like “Batman Returns” and his directorial ventures. Bringing a seasoned actor into the mix raised valid concerns about preserving the show’s quirky spirit. However, those misgivings quickly dissipated upon the crew’s initial interaction with DeVito. Olson fondly recalls the cast’s shift in perspective as a testament to DeVito’s seamless inclusion.
Their early doubts transformed into overwhelming support, as DeVito not only fitted in but also enriched the storytelling. Olson’s reflections on this turning point highlight the series’ adeptness at incorporating DeVito’s character as a natural extension of the group’s dynamics. The role was not jarring; rather, it felt as if DeVito was a perfect match, enhancing the group’s chemistry and complementing their established comedic rhythm.
The initial fan reaction paralleled the cast’s early skepticism. Many viewers, protective of the show’s original tone and energy, were hesitant about DeVito’s involvement. Nevertheless, their fears were unfounded. As viewers witnessed DeVito’s knack for elevating comedic scenes and amplifying the group’s dynamic, their acceptance quickly transitioned into genuine admiration. His addition fortified the show’s comedic foundation, allowing the original cast to excel alongside his seasoned expertise.
The significance of Danny DeVito’s casting continues to reverberate. What might initially have seemed a risky gamble turned into a masterstroke, bringing new life to “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia.” His inclusion not only expanded the show’s audience reach but also preserved its distinctive brand of humor, ensuring its longevity. As the series evolved, so too did its audience’s appreciation for DeVito’s pivotal role in its enduring success.
In retrospect, enlisting DeVito was not merely a casting decision; it was a re-envisioning of the series’ potential. His presence transformed the narrative structure and revitalized the show’s appeal. As “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia” continues to thrive, now streaming on Hulu, it stands as a testament to the lasting impact of Danny DeVito’s involvement—cementing its status as a timeless television favorite.
