Natasha Lyonne is once again at the center of awards attention as Poker Face makes a bold push for the 2025 Emmy Awards, submitting fourteen cast members for recognition in acting categories. The acclaimed Peacock comedy, which continues to build momentum, has officially placed Lyonne in contention for Best Comedy Actress for her role as Charlie Cale. This marks another major moment in Lyonne’s Emmy journey, having previously earned nominations in this category for Poker Face’s first season in 2023 and for Russian Doll in 2019, raising her career total to five nominations across acting, writing, producing, and guest performances.
Poker Face has quickly become known for its star-studded guest appearances. As Natasha Lyonne’s character, Charlie, continues her cross-country adventure solving mysteries and dodging dangerous enemies, the show’s diverse cast keeps expanding. Notably, three-time Oscar nominee Cynthia Erivo will be submitted in Guest Comedy Actress for her unique role as quintuplets in the season two premiere, joining fellow candidates Eva Jade Halford, Katie Holmes, Carol Kane, Gaby Hoffman, Margo Martindale, and Rhea Perlman.
The list for Guest Comedy Actor is no less impressive, with submissions for Giancarlo Esposito, Simon Helberg, John Mulaney, Kumail Nanjiani, Simon Rex, and Callum Vinson. The show continues its tradition of casting acclaimed and award-winning actors, building on recognition earned last year when Judith Light won Peacock’s first-ever Emmy for her guest appearance on Poker Face.
According to Gold Derby, while these fourteen cast members are confirmed for submission, actors are allowed to submit themselves, meaning even more stars from the show could appear on the official Emmy ballot. The excitement around Natasha Lyonne’s performance and the show’s guest roster is evident, with anticipation high among fans and industry experts ahead of the Emmy nominations announcement on July 15.
The significant Emmy submission effort demonstrates Poker Face’s growing impact in the comedy landscape, showcasing Natasha Lyonne’s continued influence and the willingness of celebrated performers to join her on screen. As the awards season nears, all eyes will be on how this ensemble of talent fares, with many hoping Lyonne’s craft and the collective performances will be rewarded with both nominations and wins.
