The iconic role of Alex P. Keaton on Family Ties, played by Michael J. Fox, was almost cast differently, as Michael J. Fox almost fired from Family Ties due to concerns about his suitability for the part. This pivotal decision by NBC changed the course of television in the 1980s, helping Fox become a major star and forever linking his name to the beloved sitcom.
Why Michael J. Fox Was Nearly Replaced on Family Ties
Family Ties became a breakthrough for Michael J. Fox, propelling him to fame during the height of the show‘s popularity. Yet, behind the scenes, his job security was threatened in the early days of the sitcom. According to a report from Entertainment Weekly, an influential NBC executive almost dismissed Fox because of his appearance. This moment could have altered both the show and Fox’s career trajectory.
“I wasn’t the featured character in the pilot, but my stuff all seemed to work,”
—Michael J. Fox
When the show was renewed for its first full season, executive Brandon Tartikoff reportedly advocated for Fox’s removal from the cast. Tartikoff criticized Fox’s look, doubting his potential to be a marketable television star.
“But when we had a pickup order for the first season, [executive] Brandon Tartikoff wanted to fire me. He said, ‘I love the show, you’ve just got to get rid of the kid. I can’t see that face on a lunchbox.’”
—Michael J. Fox
How Michael J. Fox Responded to Early Criticism
Despite Tartikoff’s objections, NBC executives decided to keep Michael J. Fox in the cast. As Family Ties soared in the ratings and Fox’s film career took off with Back to the Future, the young actor demonstrated to everyone—including his critics—that he was essential to the show’s charm and appeal. Fox later recalled honoring Tartikoff’s criticism with a gesture blending humor and pride.
“Years later, when Back to the Future hit and Family Ties was the number two show on TV, I made Brandon a lunchbox with my picture on it, and I wrote, ‘This is for you to put your crow in. Love, me,’”
—Michael J. Fox
Co-Stars Recognize Fox’s Humility and Talent
Michael Gross, who played the father figure on Family Ties, frequently noted Fox’s significant growth on set. He admired Fox’s combination of talent and grounded character, emphasizing how fame did not diminish Fox’s humble personality even as his star soared.
“To watch that transformation was incredible, not the least of which because Michael himself was not transformed. Michael knew he was important, he knew that he had struck gold, but nothing changed,”
—Michael Gross, Family Ties Family Patriarch
“… We were all aware that this was a big deal, but Michael was the same humble, wonderful guy.”
—Michael Gross, Family Ties Family Patriarch
The Enduring Impact of Fox’s Role on Television
Michael J. Fox’s tenure on Family Ties helped shape a generation’s television landscape, proving that early doubts about his potential were unfounded. His triumph over skepticism became a defining moment in his career, ensuring that the legacy of both Alex P. Keaton and Family Ties would endure for decades. The story of Fox almost being fired, later winning over executives and viewers alike, remains a testament to his talent and perseverance.
