Al Pacino, celebrated as one of Hollywood’s most influential figures, has openly shared his thoughts on who he believes is the greatest American actor—notably excluding frequent contender Marlon Brando, in a memorable interview. The iconic actor’s views offer fresh perspective for fans and critics invested in the ongoing debate over the Al Pacino greatest American actor discussion.
Hollywood’s Deep Pool of Talent and Pacino’s Enduring Legacy
The United States holds a distinguished place in global film history, with Hollywood’s output shaping not only the country’s culture but the international entertainment landscape as well. Over decades, the U.S. has produced a deep bench of acting talent, among whom Al Pacino stands tall. Having worked closely with legends such as Marlon Brando, Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, Val Kilmer, and James Caan, Pacino’s career has been intertwined with Hollywood’s most notable productions, including “The Godfather Part II,” “Dog Day Afternoon,” and “Scarface.”
Pacino’s career has secured him a spot among the elite, despite rare missteps like his playful performance in 2011’s “Jack and Jill.” Yet even such detours have not eclipsed his impact, buoyed by nine Oscar nominations and an Academy Award win for “Scent of a Woman” in 1992. His influence extends well beyond accolades, with his body of work often cited as foundational to the craft of acting in America.
Pacino’s Candid Thoughts on Great American Actors
In a 1979 interview with Playboy, Pacino was candid about the performers he admires. While many consider him and his frequent on-screen collaborators—such as Jack Nicholson and Robert De Niro—among the greatest, Pacino offered a broader appreciation of acting talent.
“Gary Cooper was kind of a phenomenon,”
—Al Pacino, Actor
Continuing his praise, Pacino noted the exceptional qualities of several peers:
“his ability to take something and elevate it, give it such dignity. One of the great presences. Charles Laughton was my favourite. Jack Nicholson has that kind of persona; he’s also a fine actor. Mitchum’s great. Lee Marvin, too. These guys are terrific actors”
—Al Pacino, Actor
The Surprising Choice: George C. Scott
When pressed to name the greatest of them all following the era of Marlon Brando, Pacino responded with a perhaps unexpected selection:
“Among the post-Brando actors—I call it post-Brando, it was about ten years after Brando that a lot of actors….There are so many fine actors….I don’t know. George C Scott”
—Al Pacino, Actor
This answer caught many by surprise, given Pacino’s own reverence for Brando’s legacy—Brando serving as a benchmark for subsequent generations of actors. However, Pacino’s nod to George C. Scott highlights a performer who, despite immense talent and a distinguished filmography, is rarely brought up in casual conversations about all-time greats, even by cinephiles who otherwise celebrate figures like Pacino and Brando.
George C. Scott’s Illuminated Career
George C. Scott’s career stands as a testament to his profound capabilities and versatility. Best known for earning an Oscar for his commanding performance as General George S. Patton in the 1970 film “Patton,” Scott frequently worked with esteemed directors including Stanley Kubrick, Peter Medak, Paul Schrader, and Otto Preminger. His portrayal of the unhinged General ‘Buck’ Turgidson in Kubrick’s “Dr. Strangelove” remains, for many contemporary audiences, a defining role of his storied career.
Pacino’s Admiration for Notable Filmmakers
While discussing actors, Al Pacino also shared his enthusiasm for extraordinary directors shaping the industry landscape. He expressed particular admiration for Mel Brooks and Woody Allen, underscoring the lasting impact and comedic brilliance found in their body of work:
“Mel Brooks will have these flashes in his films; you laugh for hours afterward. I wonder how he is, what he’s like. The same with Woody; I go to see all of his films”
—Al Pacino, Actor
Looking Ahead: Rethinking Greatness in American Acting
Al Pacino’s personal choice stands as a reminder of the diversity and depth within American cinema. By highlighting George C. Scott, Pacino broadens the conversation beyond widely recognized giants like Marlon Brando, prompting fans and film scholars to revisit Scott’s legendary performances. With his decades of influence and thoughtful perspective, Pacino continues sparking dialogue about what defines the greatest American actor, ensuring his own legacy remains tightly woven with those he chooses to celebrate.
