Jon Bernthal appeared in a supporting role in the 2025 film The Amateur, which has quickly risen to the top of the streaming charts despite receiving mixed reviews. Released on April 11 in the U.S., the movie’s combination of action and espionage moments has sparked calls for a sequel that would better explore its potential.
Jon Bernthal’s Role as a CIA Operative Adds Depth to The Amateur
In The Amateur, Jon Bernthal plays Jackson O’Brien, a seasoned CIA operative who assists the main character, played by Rami Malek. Their dynamic highlights a sharp contrast: Malek’s character is a resourceful but inexperienced individual, while Bernthal embodies the hardened intelligence agent. Although Bernthal’s screen time is limited, his presence adds tension and credibility to the film’s espionage atmosphere.
Bernthal’s character plays both supportive and obstructive roles in the story, helping the protagonist on his path for vengeance but also attempting to restrain him at times. Critics noted Bernthal’s cool and commanding screen presence but lamented that his role did not significantly advance the story’s deeper layers or character development. This underuse of such a talented actor left some viewers frustrated, especially fans familiar with Bernthal’s intense performances, such as his portrayal of Frank Castle in Marvel’s The Punisher series.
While The Amateur was met with criticism for its predictable plot and lack of originality, Bernthal’s performance was one of the film’s rare highlights, reinforcing the possibility that his character could hold more importance in future installments.
The Amateur’s Streaming Success and Audience Reception
Despite receiving mixed critical feedback, The Amateur has resonated strongly with general viewers, as evidenced by its dominant position at the top of Disney+ streaming charts in the U.S., according to Flix Patrol data. The film’s audience score stands at an impressive 88% on Rotten Tomatoes, reflecting widespread viewer appreciation even with its flaws.
Many audiences have praised the film’s focus on clever tactics and technology-driven action sequences, rather than relying solely on typical gunfights or hand-to-hand combat. This emphasis on intelligence and strategy gives the film a refreshing edge within the spy-thriller genre.
Rami Malek’s portrayal of the lead character has also received favorable remarks, with his nuanced acting balancing the tension and vulnerability necessary for a story centered on espionage and personal revenge.
Why The Amateur Warrants a Sequel and Expansion
One of the notable aspects of The Amateur is how it leaves several narrative threads unresolved, setting the stage for a potential continuation. The mentorship relationship between Bernthal’s Jackson O’Brien and Malek’s protagonist is hinted at but not fully developed, suggesting there may be much more to explore in future films.
The film’s open-ended conclusion and incomplete character arcs present opportunities for deeper storytelling, particularly focusing on Bernthal’s character, whose full capabilities and backstory have yet to be revealed.
Critics argue that while the film lacked originality and was a patchwork of familiar spy thriller elements, it still contained enough compelling performances and innovative action sequences to justify expanding into a sequel. There is a clear demand for sharpening the plot and building on the characters’ complexities, which a follow-up could address.
The mixed critical reception, paired with the strong audience interest and streaming success, signals that The Amateur could transform into a more robust franchise if the next installment allows Jon Bernthal’s character to take a central, fully realized role.
As viewers continue to debate the film’s strengths and weaknesses, one point remains evident: Jon Bernthal’s The Amateur sequel has significant potential both creatively and commercially.
The Amateur is currently available to stream in the USA on Disney+.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. What is Jon Bernthal’s religion?
A. Jonathan Edward Bernthal was born in Washington, D.C. on September 20, 1976. He comes from a Jewish family.
