Actor Will Arnett shared a memorable and nerve-wracking story about his audition for Oscar-winning director Kevin Costner’s 1997 film, The Postman. Despite the usual jitters for any actor trying to impress a box-office giant, Arnett’s main concern during the audition was a personal emergency that nearly derailed his entire performance. This Kevin Costner Audition Story reveals how close Arnett came to a disastrous moment that had nothing to do with his acting skills.
Struggles the Night Before the Audition
The night before meeting Kevin Costner, Arnett fell ill after eating bad food, requiring a hospital visit for severe dehydration. He described how long he had been away from a bathroom, making the situation all the more difficult on the morning of the audition. Arnett’s discomfort grew as he sat down to read for Costner’s western, not because of the famous director’s presence but because of his pressing need to avoid an embarrassing accident.
I legitimately was worried about c–pping my pants‚
Arnett, 55, recalled during a recent interview on the show Hot Ones.
The night before, I had eaten something bad. I ended up going to the hospital because I was so dehydrated from being ill,
he revealed.
That was the furthest I’d been away from the bathroom in like 14 hours.

By 1997, Costner, 71, had already earned two Academy Awards, while Arnett was still waiting for his big acting breakthrough. The tension of trying to stay composed under these physical challenges almost overshadowed the audition itself.
A Chaotic Moment in an Unlucky Role
Arnett remembers the cold sweat and panic as he fought to maintain control during the audition. Instead of focusing on acting, his thoughts centered on the worst possible scenario.
I was meeting Kevin Costner, and I legitimately was worried about c–ping my pants.
Ultimately, Arnett did not secure the role in the film, which later became infamous for its critical reception. The Postman went on to sweep the 1998 Razzie Awards, winning Worst Picture, Worst Actor, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay, and Worst Original Song. In hindsight, missing out on this part might have spared Arnett from being associated with one of Hollywood’s most heavily criticized projects.
Continued Anxiety Over Spicy Food and Public Appearances
Decades later, Arnett faced a similar kind of anxiety while filming Hot Ones, a show where guests eat increasingly spicy chicken wings during interviews. Arnett revealed that his nerves aren’t limited to auditions but extend to eating spicy food in front of others.
I‘m so nervous about eating hot food. I can’t even watch people eat hot food, spicy food,
he admitted.
He initially hesitated to appear on the show due to fears of embarrassing himself again.
I liked the idea, but I feel like I’m gonna embarrass myself,
Arnett shared with his publicist.
I’m gonna have to wear a Depend during taping.
Despite his worries, Arnett completed the episode without a repeat incident. However, the heat of the wings prompted him to jokingly ask about medical procedures.
How much is lip replacement surgery? Is that even a thing?
he asked.
My mouth wants to leave my body.
Current Projects and Career Progression
Will Arnett’s early career involved small roles in low-budget films and guest appearances on television until he landed his breakthrough in 2003 with the comedy series Arrested Development. Today, he is the Emmy-nominated star of Is This Thing On?, a film directed by Bradley Cooper about a comedian navigating the fallout of his divorce through stand-up material. The movie debuted at the New York Film Festival and is available in theaters now.
Reflection on Arnett’s Audition and Its Lasting Impact
This vivid Kevin Costner Audition Story highlights how external pressures can affect even talented actors during crucial moments in their careers. Although Arnett’s physical distress prevented him from landing a part in The Postman, his perseverance led to enduring success in television and film. His candid reflections on anxiety—whether about auditions or eating spicy wings—offer a glimpse of the vulnerabilities shared by many performers.

