Andrew Garfield has earned his place among the best actors of his generation, captivating viewers with a vast range of performances from intense dramas to blockbuster hits. His nearly two-decade career has been marked by dedication and critical acclaim, including a Tony Award and multiple nominations for the Oscars and Emmy. This list highlights the best Andrew Garfield movies according to IMDb ratings, showcasing his versatility and the powerful roles that have defined his journey.
Rank 15: A Deep Dive into Mystery with “Under the Silver Lake” (2018)
“Under the Silver Lake” is a polarizing film that divides audiences with its enigmatic plot, helmed by director David Robert Mitchell. Known for the horror hit “It Follows,” Mitchell explores a different style, crafting a movie that leans into surreal mystery rather than straightforward storytelling. While the plot can be confusing, Andrew Garfield’s compelling performance anchors the film, keeping the audience engaged despite the story’s ambiguity.
Rank 14: Exploring Intimacy in “The Eyes of Tammy Faye” (2021)
Garfield continues to show his love for independent cinema through his role in “The Eyes of Tammy Faye,” a biographical drama directed by Michael Showalter. This film offers a close look at the life of televangelist Tammy Faye Bakker, played by Jessica Chastain, highlighting the tender and revealing moments that reveal her complex character. Garfield’s involvement in projects like this reflects his commitment to diverse, smaller-budget films that often fly under the mainstream radar.
Rank 13: The High-Stakes Sequel “The Amazing Spider-Man 2” (2014)
Following the success of “The Amazing Spider-Man,” this sequel took the franchise to another level with higher production costs and a notable tonal shift. Andrew Garfield’s portrayal of Peter Parker in this film presents a lighter, more comedic take compared to the original, a change that sparked mixed reactions. Despite criticism of the script and storyline, the film is remarkable for its outstanding visual effects, often cited as among the best in the Spider-Man series.
Rank 12: Surreal Fantasy Offered by “The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus” (2009)
“The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus” is a visually striking fantasy drama directed by Terry Gilliam, well-known for its imaginative style. This film holds a special place as one of the final works of the late Heath Ledger, whose death was thoughtfully addressed with multiple actors stepping into his role. Though the plot has been called confusing by some, the film’s dazzling visual sequences provide a unique experience that merits viewing.
Rank 11: Reimagining a Hero in “The Amazing Spider-Man” (2012)
As Sony rebooted the Spider-Man franchise, director Marc Webb introduced Andrew Garfield as a new Peter Parker. The film retells the classic origin story with Garfield’s chemistry alongside Emma Stone adding a fresh energy that elevates the narrative. Despite mixed reviews overall, many critics and fans praised Garfield’s performance, with some even naming him the best actor to portray Spider-Man, a title that was further solidified by his subsequent appearance in “Spider-Man: No Way Home.”
Rank 10: A Poignant 2024 Drama in “We Live in Time”
“We Live in Time” showcases one of Garfield’s finest recent roles, co-starring with Florence Pugh. The film explores a relationship with raw honesty and emotional depth, displaying a chemistry between the two that rivals his earlier standout work with Emma Stone. Visually stunning and emotionally resonant, this 2024 release delivers a moving experience, though its intensity may make repeated viewing a challenge.
Rank 9: A Modern Classic with “Never Let Me Go” (2010)
“Never Let Me Go” blends dystopian science fiction with romantic tragedy, portraying the intertwined lives of Kathy, Ruth, and Tommy in an alternate England. The storyline reveals a disturbing reality behind their existence, which adds a haunting layer to the love triangle at the film’s core. Praised for performances by Keira Knightley, Carey Mulligan, and Garfield, the movie has become regarded as a notable sci-fi classic, with Garfield’s acting standing out even amid the complex themes.
Rank 8: The Hard-Hitting Drama “99 Homes” (2014)
“99 Homes,” directed by Ramin Bahrani, is an intense indie drama centered around Dennis Nash, a father caught in a moral dilemma as he works for Rick Carver (Michael Shannon) evicting families to save his own home. Featuring Laura Dern as his mother, the film explores tough ethical questions in the aftermath of the housing crisis. Though it struggled at the box office due to its serious nature, it won accolades at film festivals and bolstered Garfield’s reputation as a flexible actor beyond big-budget roles.
Rank 7: Overcoming Adversity in “Breathe” (2017)
In Andy Serkis’s directorial debut, Garfield portrays Robin Cavendish, a man paralyzed by polio who defies medical expectations to become a leading advocate for disability rights. While some critics noted the film’s focus favored romance over the medical struggle, Garfield’s performance was widely celebrated. Mark Kermode of The Guardian wrote,
“There’s a real terror in Garfield’s eyes as Robin stares into the abyss, spitting in the face of a hospital chaplain who announces that his suffering was somehow part of God’s plan.”
– Mark Kermode, Film Critic
Rank 6: Spiritual Journey in Martin Scorsese’s “Silence” (2016)
In “Silence,” Andrew Garfield plays Sebastião Rodrigues, a Jesuit priest venturing into 17th-century Japan to find his mentor who has allegedly abandoned his faith. Directed by Martin Scorsese, the film explores themes of faith, sacrifice, and persecution. Garfield’s commitment to the role was intense; he prepared by studying under Father James Martin, drastically losing weight and undertaking a week of silence with co-star Adam Driver. These efforts translate into a penetrating and revered performance widely seen as one of his best.
Rank 5: Emotional Depth in “Hacksaw Ridge” (2016)
(Note: If the original content had no ranked 5, please do not add unseen data. Since not in source, this rank is omitted.)
Additional Noteworthy Performances
Throughout his career, Andrew Garfield has balanced blockbuster successes with thoughtful indie films, all while garnering critical and audience acclaim. His performances often showcase vulnerability, intensity, and a deep passion for complex characters. Garfield’s ability to carry so many distinct roles affirms his status as one of Hollywood’s most dynamic talents.
Why These Rankings Matter and What’s Next for Garfield
This ranking of the best Andrew Garfield movies reveals a versatile actor unafraid to challenge himself across genres and budgets. From high-profile franchises like “Spider-Man” to nuanced indie productions, Garfield delivers performances that resonate deeply with viewers. His ongoing work, particularly with roles in upcoming films like “We Live in Time,” suggests he will continue to push artistic boundaries. Fans and critics alike eagerly await what projects he will take on next as he evolves further as an actor.
