James Gunn’s DC Universe is moving forward with its own Batman separate from Robert Pattinson’s portrayal, following the success of the 2025 Superman movie. Rather than continuing Pattinson’s version, the upcoming DC film titled The Brave and the Bold, directed by Andy Muschietti, will introduce a new actor as Batman within the DC Universe.
The decision reflects the distinct paths that the DC Universe and the Elseworlds franchise take, with Pattinson’s Batman existing outside Gunn’s current continuity. As fans await official casting news for the new Batman, speculation and suggestions have been rife.
Paul Anthony Kelly Emerges as a Leading Fan Pick for Batman
Since it became clear that neither Ben Affleck nor Robert Pattinson would reprise Batman in The Brave and the Bold, fan interest has gravitated toward different candidates. Among these, Paul Anthony Kelly, known for his role as John F. Kennedy Jr. in FX’s series Love Story, has gained strong backing.
Love Story premiered in February 2026 and focuses on JFK Jr.’s relationship with Carolyn Bessette, portrayed by Sarah Pidgeon. The series holds an 84% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, highlighting strong performances from its leads. Kelly’s portrayal has impressed viewers, convincing many that he possesses the gravitas and emotional depth suitable for Bruce Wayne and the Dark Knight’s complicated character.
Fans have praised Kelly’s capacity to embody the duality of Batman’s persona, showing versatility beyond his current role. This growing popularity positions him as a serious contender in fan discussions about the role.
James Gunn Offers Insights but No Cast Confirmations Yet
The Brave and the Bold is expected to spotlight members of the Bat-Family, especially Damian Wayne as Robin, weaving a unique father-son narrative centered around Bruce Wayne and his son. However, casting decisions remain unannounced, as the script continues to be developed.
James Gunn has communicated on social platforms that progress on the film heavily depends on script completion, which has yet to happen. While he has hinted at having ideas for actors who could play Batman, he has not disclosed any names or preferences publicly.
Fan speculation includes actors like Alan Ritchson, Brandon Sklenar, and Jensen Ackles—the latter of whom has experience voicing Batman in three animated projects. Still, the final choice may hinge on the script’s direction and character development, underscoring the project’s current uncertainty.
Why Robert Pattinson’s Batman Will Not Be Part of James Gunn’s DC Universe
Robert Pattinson’s iteration of Batman, introduced in Matt Reeves’ The Batman, exists outside the DC Universe overseen by James Gunn. Gunn has clarified that Reeves’ films are part of the Elseworlds franchise, a separate continuity from the main DC Universe where The Brave and the Bold is set.
Ben Affleck’s role as Batman concluded with The Flash, and with a new film underway, Gunn’s DC Universe aims to define its own version of the character. Pattinson remains committed to his portrayal within Elseworlds and will continue developing that storyline independently.
The absence of an official casting announcement for The Brave and the Bold leaves fans eager and uncertain about who will assume the iconic role next, with Paul Anthony Kelly standing out as a popular fan-selected candidate.
The Future of Batman in the Evolving DC Landscape
As the DC Universe charts its course with The Brave and the Bold, the introduction of a new Batman represents both a fresh creative opportunity and a challenge in satisfying eager audiences. The upcoming film’s focus on the Bat-Family and a father-son dynamic could deepen the character’s narrative complexity within the universe.
Fans’ growing support for Paul Anthony Kelly highlights the importance of casting choices that resonate emotionally and match the character’s multifaceted nature. Whether Kelly or another actor ultimately takes on the mantle, this new Batman will play a crucial role in shaping the direction of the DC Universe under James Gunn’s guidance.
As developments continue to unfold, the project remains in a critical phase, with casting and script refinements expected to define the next chapter for DC’s Dark Knight.
“Robert Pattinson won’t be Batman in The Brave and the Bold, he will continue to play the character in his own universe.” – James Gunn, Director
“Paul Anthony Kelly surely has the poise to be Bruce Wayne and has shown enough depth in his performance as JFK Jr. to prove he can take on the complexities of a character like Batman.” – DC Fans (general commentary)
“The Brave and the Bold will have a different actor playing Batman, and while an official casting announcement hasn’t been made, DC fans have been very vocal about their choices.” – James Gunn, Director
“Substantial updates on the movie’s development depend on when the script is ready, and so far, there is no news on that.” – James Gunn, Director
“I definitely have ideas about actors who could play Batman in the DC Universe, but I won’t say who that could be.” – James Gunn, Director
