James Gunn, co-head of DC Studios and director of the upcoming Superman film, ignited intense discussions among fans by sharing a message celebrating Lex Luthor, one of the Man of Steel’s most famous adversaries. Highlighting Luthor’s comic book origins, Gunn stirred controversy by suggesting the character might not be a villain, instead portraying him as Earth’s protector. This unexpected claim has slowed the usual clear-cut distinction between hero and villain within the DC universe.
How Gunn Reframed Lex Luthor’s Legacy
In a social media post marking Lex Luthor’s anniversary since his first appearance in Superman #4, created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, Gunn characterized him as
“the ambitious and unstoppable CEO and scientist Lex Luthor,”
emphasizing that he is “most definitely NOT a villain,” but rather a “protector of earth and humanity.” Gunn underlined this portrayal by noting Luthor’s sworn commitment “on a stack of Bibles.” This reinterpretation challenges established perceptions, as fans immediately recalled Luthor’s controversial deeds.
Complementing his statement, Gunn teased the film Man of Tomorrow, set for release in summer 2027, where Luthor reportedly collaborates with Superman. He wrote,
“We’ll see how he does working with arch-nemesis Superman in MAN OF TOMORROW, in theaters summer of 27.”
The post illuminated Gunn’s intention to explore a more intricate relationship between the two central figures of the DC universe.
Fan Backlash Highlights Luthor’s Villainous Actions on Screen
Gunn’s depiction of Lex Luthor as a protector met swift resistance from fans recalling the character’s actions in the 2025 Superman film. Nicholas Hoult’s portrayal of Luthor in that movie featured decisions and behaviors that many considered unquestionably villainous. Social media responses quickly pointed to Luthor’s willingness to let people die in a catastrophic event called the rift, conflicting with any image of heroism.
One fan remarked,
“Even though in Superman, he was willing to allow People to die in the rift 🤣 but he’s still the ‘protector’.”
— Cyril Gittens
Meanwhile, others called out Luthor’s direct violence. Another user wrote,
“I’m still trying to wrap my head around how he is not a villain because he literally killed an innocent man in the previous movie.”
— Raghav Aggarwal 👨💻 🚀
A third commenter added a sarcastic note,
“Didn’t he execute an innocent falafel cart vendor? Bro should be in prison for that alone, falafels are great.”
— J
These reactions underscore the difficulty in reconciling Gunn’s hero angle with established on-screen facts.
Exploring the Complexity of Lex Luthor’s Character in the New DCU
Despite the criticism, Gunn appears to be preparing for a deeper exploration of Lex Luthor’s motivations in Man of Tomorrow. The film is expected to delve into a more nuanced portrayal, showing Luthor and Superman working together in a way that challenges traditional rivalries. One fan expressed enthusiasm for this development, stating,
“Lex Luthor as hero? That’s a plot twist I didn’t see coming! Can’t wait to see the dynamic with Superman in MAN OF TOMORROW.”
— CODE
The anticipation for this complex relationship suggests the partnership will be central to the film’s narrative and emotional core.
Upcoming Film Details and the Continuing Story of Lex Luthor
Man of Tomorrow, directed by James Gunn, is scheduled for release in the United States on July 9, 2027, under DC Studios and Warner Bros. Pictures. Serving as a follow-up to 2025’s Superman, the film will continue to expand the freshly revamped DC Universe. David Corenswet returns to portray Clark Kent and Superman, while Nicholas Hoult reprises his role as Lex Luthor. The cast also includes Lars Eidinger as Brainiac, introducing an additional prominent DC villain to the story.
Production is expected to begin later this year, with Hoult’s version of Luthor already established in previous projects, including a cameo in Peacemaker Season 2. This continuation points to a long-term commitment from Gunn to develop Luthor’s character comprehensively across the new DC landscape.
Comic Roots and the Challenge of Translating Luthor’s Morality on Screen
The idea of Lex Luthor as a self-styled guardian of Earth is not new to the comics. Traditionally, Luthor views Superman as the real threat to humanity, advocating that human intellect rather than alien power should govern the planet. This ideological conflict forms the basis of many storylines, complicating the hero-villain dichotomy. However, bringing this complexity into live-action films while addressing Luthor’s violent and ethically questionable actions presents a considerable storytelling challenge for Gunn and his team.
Fans and critics alike will be watching closely to see how this reinterpretation unfolds and whether it changes perceptions of one of DC’s most enduring characters. The ongoing James Gunn Lex Luthor debate highlights the evolving nature of comic book adaptations and the intricacies involved in presenting iconic figures with added depth.
Ultimately, the question remains: is Lex Luthor a villain through and through, or can there be room in the DC Universe for him to be seen as the hero of his own story?
Even though in Superman, he was willing to allow People to die in the rift 🤣 but he’s still the “protector” pic.twitter.com/U766QIHvdy
— Cyril Gittens (@PistolaPedro22) February 23, 2026
I'm still trying to wrap my head around how he is not a villain because he literally killed an innocent man in the previous movie.
— Raghav Aggarwal 👨💻 🚀 (@avidRaghav) February 23, 2026
Didn’t he execute an innocent falafel cart vendor?
Bro should be in prison for that alone, falafels are great— J (@Luckydragon84) February 23, 2026
Lex Luthor as hero? That’s a plot twist I didn’t see coming! Can’t wait to see the dynamic with Superman in MAN OF TOMORROW.
— CODE (@_CODEwalker) February 23, 2026
Related semantic context: related coverage · external reference.