As Marvel fans speculate about the possible return of Chris Evans, renewed attention falls on which Captain America variants Chris Evans could play in Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars. Despite public statements from Evans suggesting his adoption of the shield has ended, the nature of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) and its dive into the Multiverse open the door for the actor to take on bold, unexpected versions of the hero in upcoming films.
Recent rumors and ongoing Multiversal storylines fuel excitement for seeing Evans rejoin iconic characters like Sam Wilson, Peggy Carter, and others. With alternate realities, there are many possibilities for Steve Rogers, and the following list explores eight standout Captain America variants, each presenting a different challenge for Evans and offering fans something new to anticipate.
Old Man Rogers: The Veteran Hero Returns
While Marvel Studios has left Steve Rogers’ current status on Earth-616 unclear, with hints suggesting he may be gone, his storyline’s emotional endpoint with Peggy Carter remains fresh. Fans last saw Rogers travel back in time for a personal ending, only to return to bestow his shield on Sam Wilson.
The possibility persists that Steve Rogers could be living quietly, only to make a comeback as “Old Man Rogers.” Clad in new armor and experienced from a life of battles, this version would still possess traces of the Super Soldier Serum and could test the hero’s limits before a possible restoration of his youth. This scenario is especially compelling since it could allow Chris Evans to examine Rogers’ vulnerabilities and wisdom after decades of heroic service, blending nostalgia and adventure in the upcoming Avengers films.
Civil Warrior: When Steve Embraces a Darker Path
Exploring Steve Rogers’ more shadowy sides, the Civil Warrior variant comes directly from the Marvel: Contest of Champions mobile game, where Rogers’ conflict with Iron Man ends in tragedy. After defeating Tony Stark, this Captain America integrates parts of Stark’s armor—most notably, the Arc Reactor—into his equipment, resulting in a compelling fusion of two legendary Avengers.
This darker, more conflicted version of Rogers would create powerful tension with Earth-616’s surviving heroes, especially given how integral the original Civil War story is to the wider MCU. If Doctor Doom or another villain summoned such a variant to join their cause, fans could expect Evans to portray the internal turmoil of a Captain America haunted by the consequences of his choices and the burden of power taken to the extreme.
Zombie Captain America: The Horrors of the Undead Multiverse
Marvel’s animated series What If…? already introduced a zombified Steve Rogers, but the live-action potential remains untapped. On the comic book page, some versions of Zombie Cap—such as Colonel Rogers—have gone even further, showing a Captain America who was once the President and ultimately transformed into a brain-devouring threat by the Red Skull.
If Chris Evans were to assume the role of an undead version of his iconic character, fans could expect a blend of horror and shock value. Should heroes discover this grotesque variant during a cross-universe mission, Evans’ performance might balance tragedy and menace, demonstrating how far a beloved hero can fall when twisted by supernatural forces.
Cap-Wolf: The Avenger Unleashes His Wild Side
The Cap-Wolf storyline stands out as one of the wildest transformations for Steve Rogers. Originating in the comics when Rogers was infected by a virus created by Nightshade, he transforms into a werewolf—retaining his heroic principles but wrestling with wild, animalistic instincts.
Fans often consider Cap-Wolf a cult favorite. Later depicted as an Earth-666 variant, this monstrous form fits into a world where the Avengers themselves are creatures of legend. For Avengers: Doomsday or Secret Wars, Evans taking on this unusual persona with the help of visual effects could push the limits of what audiences expect from a superhero film, offering both heroism and bestial fury within the same character.
Soldier Supreme: Combining the Strength of Cap and Sorcery
First appearing in the 2018 Infinity Wars event, Soldier Supreme seamlessly merges Captain America with Doctor Strange. The amalgam has Rogers’ enhanced abilities and martial prowess, overlaid with the mystic arts wielded by Strange himself, granting an entirely new dimension to the classic super-soldier’s power.
This hybrid variant delivers not only physical combat but also the mystery of magic, giving Evans the opportunity to explore magic-driven storytelling within the familiar context of Steve Rogers. If this version steps into battle, his relationship with iconic characters like Doctor Doom and others could shift, possibly reprising or even extending some of Strange’s influential roles in the Secret Wars saga.
President Rogers: When the Shield Aligns With the Oval Office
Several alternate realities in Marvel lore have seen Captain America take on the role of President of the United States. Recent glimpses in What If…? have introduced viewers to these powerful adaptations of Steve Rogers, combining American leadership with superhero vigilance.
This variant could be depicted in tandem with others—imagine Avengers traveling to a parallel Earth, arriving in the White House, and discovering an undead Colonel Rogers at the helm. Whether as a benevolent reformer committed to saving his world or a tyrant ruling with an iron fist, President Rogers introduces new questions of morality and leadership, enriching the complexity of upcoming Multiversal conflicts.
World War II Captain America: Soldier Out of Time
With the state of the MCU’s Multiverse unstable, it’s plausible for the Avengers to enlist a Steve Rogers straight from the World War II battlefields. Plucked from combat against the likes of HYDRA or even imagined continuations of the global conflict, this younger Rogers would again be a fish out of water—tasked with challenges and stakes that far exceed his original mission.
Whether originating from the well-known Earth-616 timeline or a world where the classic war never reached its canonical close, this Captain America would need to quickly adapt to Multiversal threats. Evans revisiting the blend of innocence and determination that defined his earliest appearances could evoke a potent mix of nostalgia and fresh narrative possibilities.
Hydra Cap: Embracing the Shadows
Of all the ominous variants, Hydra Cap is arguably the darkest. The character’s comic book arc reveals that the Steve Rogers fans know had, thanks to reality alteration via a sentient Cosmic Cube, secretly been a HYDRA agent since childhood. Eventually, the evil Hydra Cap and the original Steve are split into separate characters, providing a direct antagonist who wields the familiar shield for destructive aims.
A villainous Captain America would bring Chris Evans into a radically new dynamic, especially interacting with figures like Doctor Doom or the assembled Avengers. The potential for confrontation and philosophical conflict would add gravitas and shock to the epic scale of the Multiverse battles, challenging audiences’ notions of loyalty and identity.
As Marvel Studios continues to expand its Multiversal storyline, each Captain America variant Chris Evans could play in Avengers: Doomsday or Secret Wars offers fresh ways to reexamine Steve Rogers. From the wisdom of Old Man Rogers to the chilling duality of Hydra Cap, these new faces hold promise for unexpected twists and heightened dramatic stakes—not only for Evans as an actor but for the MCU as a whole. Fans and creators alike await word on whether these possibilities will become reality on the big screen.
